Brooks Brothers American-Made Oxford Cloth Button-Down Dress Shirt, 1900 · The originator, still made
Materials
Not stated · No fibre composition in the listing
Gitman's Oxford cloth button-down shirt, patterned on the Brooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford Shirt of 1900. It keeps the Oxford cloth and button-down collar; the single patch chest pocket differ from the Original Polo Button-Down Oxford Shirt: a single plain patch chest pocket; the soft, unlined collar with a roll, back box pleat, locker loop and button barrel cuffs cannot be made out. The listing says nothing about construction and says it is made in United States.
Reference · the Brooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford Shirt
John E. Brooks, grandson of the founder, watched a polo match in England in 1896 and noticed that the players' collar points were buttoned down so they would not flap during play. In 1900 Brooks Brothers put the buttoned collar on its ready-made shirts in New York, calling them polo shirts; the collar was then applied to oxford cloth and the shirt spread through East Coast colleges, where it was common by 1915.
How the Oxford cloth button-down shirt changed, 1900s-1920s to present
1900s–1920sBrooks Brothers sells the buttoned "polo" collar on ready-made shirts from 1900. By 1915 the shirt is common at East Coast colleges, and the collar moves onto oxford cloth to make the shirt now called the OCBD.
1949–1960sGant of New Haven (founded 1949) sells its button-downs through the Yale Co-op and adds the locker loop, box pleat and back-collar button. The shirt is the uniform of the Ivy League look; the Japanese photo book Take Ivy (1965) records it on campus and carries the style to Japan. Brooks Brothers adds a chest pocket in 1968.
1980s–1990sThe Official Preppy Handbook (1980) names the Brooks Brothers shirt and "that perfect roll to the collar" as preppy essentials. After Marks & Spencer buys Brooks Brothers in 1988 the collar is lined and fused, flattening the roll, and sold that way for about 25 years; the shirt is made at every price point.
2016–presentBrooks Brothers restores the unlined collar in 2016 and drops the pocket, raising the price from $95 to $140; it closes its North Carolina shirt factory in 2020 and the shirt is imported. J.Crew, Uniqlo and others sell washed, slim and stretch versions; fused collars, shorter points and side pleats are the norm below about $100.
Oxford clothSame
The Brooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford Shirt and this product both have a basketweave oxford cloth.
A cotton basketweave in which single weft yarns cross pairs of warp yarns, giving a textured, slightly lustrous cloth heavier than poplin or broadcloth. In classic colours one yarn is dyed and the other white, which gives the faint heathered look.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtNo clear viewThis product
Button-down collarSame
The Brooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford Shirt and this product both have a button-down collar.
The collar points fasten to the shirt front with two small buttons, the detail Brooks Brothers took from polo players in 1896.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtThis product · photo: Gitman
Soft, unlined collar with a rollUnclear
The listing does not say, and the soft, unlined collar with a roll cannot be made out.
The original collar had long points and no interlining, so that when buttoned it curves outward in a soft roll that changes with the wearer's posture. Brooks Brothers lined and fused the collar from the late 1980s and removed the interlining again in 2016 to restore the roll.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtThis product · photo: Gitman
Back box pleatUnclear
The listing does not say, and the back box pleat cannot be made out.
A box pleat below the back yoke gives room across the shoulders. Gant of New Haven added it to its shirts in the 1950s, and it became a standard Ivy detail.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtNo clear viewThis product
Locker loopUnclear
The listing does not say, and the locker loop cannot be made out.
A hanging loop ("locker loop") at the top of the back pleat. Gant of New Haven added it, with a button at the back of the collar, to its shirts in the 1950s, and both became standard Ivy details.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtNo clear viewThis product
Single patch chest pocketDiffers
The Brooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford Shirt has no chest pocket; this product has a single plain patch chest pocket.
One patch pocket on the left chest. The Brooks Brothers shirt had none until 1968; the pocket was removed again in the 2016 reissue, so either is faithful to some period of the original.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtThis product · photo: Gitman
Button barrel cuffsUnclear
The listing does not say, and the button barrel cuffs cannot be made out.
Single-button barrel cuffs, unlined on the original, rather than French cuffs, in keeping with the shirt's sporting origin.
No clear viewBrooks Brothers Original Polo Button-Down Oxford ShirtThis product · photo: Gitman
Construction
Expected at this price2 detailsWhat a Oxford cloth button-down shirt should state
Stated by the listing0 of 2Nothing on seams, tacks or finishing
What it does sayOxfordand button down collar and chest pocket; no construction claims
A well-made Oxford cloth button-down shirt usually has single-needle stitching, gussets; the listing does not say. Silence is not a verdict: a maker that does these things usually says so, and each can be checked in a minute with the product in hand.
Single-needle stitching
Listing: not stated
Shirt seams sewn one row at a time with a single needle, each seam allowance folded and sewn in two passes, instead of two rows at once on a two-needle machine.
What it tells you
A traditional marker of better shirtmaking: single-needle seams lie flatter, pucker less after washing, and take roughly twice as long to sew as a double-needle felled seam. Common on dress shirts and heritage oxfords; stated on the listing when a maker does it.
How to check it yourself
Look at the side seams and armholes of the shirt from the outside: one row of stitching, with a narrow flat seam, rather than two parallel rows.
Gussets
Listing: not stated
A small extra piece of fabric, often a triangle or diamond, sewn into a seam junction to add strength or room: at the bottom of a shirt's side seam, under the arm, or at the crotch of trousers.
What it tells you
A detail from traditional shirtmaking and workwear that costs a pattern piece and some sewing; a side-seam gusset stops the hem splitting where the side seam ends, a crotch gusset lets trousers move without strain.
How to check it yourself
On a shirt, look at the bottom of each side seam for a small triangle of fabric; on trousers, inside the crotch for a diamond-shaped panel.